Sunday, 8 January 2017

To what extent is hip-hop instrumental in allowing for social commentary on the issue of police brutality?

‘When we consider hip hop’s origins and purpose, we understand it is a revolutionary cultural force that was intended to challenge the status quo and greater American culture’ - (Asante, 2008)[1]

To what extent is hip-hop instrumental in allowing for social commentary on the issue of police brutality?

Having only been formed just under 50 years ago in the Bronx borough of New York City, the genre of hip-hop is one that has seen many evolutions take place within it. Initially it acted as an outlet ‘chiefly concerned with the social conditions of (black) working-class (urban life)’[2] or struggles whether that relate to marginalisation or racism. Rap groups from the 1980s and 90s like the NWA and Geto Boys exemplified and embodied this, through the release of their songs ‘F*ck Da Police’ and ‘Crooked Officer’ respectively. Fast forward to 2016 and things aren't at all the same. 'Mainstream' has taken a hold, where commercialism and braggadocio are conventions held at the utmost importance, with hip-hop even being referred to as ‘the very language of the advertising world.’[3] However this doesn't mean that the genre as a form of social commentary has been totally eradicated. In the case of police brutality, 'the use of excessive and/or unnecessary force by police when dealing with civilians'[4] which is something that's been rife in the USA since the Civil Rights Movement, artists like Joey Bada$$ are still taking it upon themselves to address the issue. His 'Like Me' video, released amidst the deaths of individuals like Trayvon Martin and Michael Brown at the hands of police brutality, depicts a fictional case of it which other artists like Kendrick Lamar and YG have also followed in the line of. This is representative of the influence that the artists have through their music to shine light on social issues to their listeners. At the same time though, while commentary is allowed for through the genre, the effectiveness of it in actually solving issues like police brutality are yet to be seen and this essay will explore whether it’s capable of it at all.

In response to the ‘last few years of heightened public attention to shootings of unarmed black men,’[5] on February 11th 2015 through the YouTube channel of his record label Pro Era Records, Joey Bada$$ published the video for Like Me (a song off of his debut studio album B4.DA.$$). Being over 5 minutes in length, the video takes the theme of police brutality and threads in a whole narrative element to it featuring Joey himself as the main character.  ‘Embroiled in a love triangle, Joey ends up held at gunpoint by his girl’s ex, then escapes when police shoot both of them during the chaos. Later, police find him again and shoot when he tries to flee the scene.’[6] The representation of black males throughout the course of this video is significant as it both reinforces and subverts stereotypes in particularly interesting ways.

In a scene involving Joey’s love interest’s ex, we’re presented with what is a common portrayal of the young black man of today. During the late-night hours the ex and two others ready up to perform a mugging on a passer-by. Looking at him in particular just moments before approaching the soon-to-be victim, a slow motion medium close up shot shows him raising his hood, already donning a blue bandana as well as a snapback cap. This type of clothing alone has certain connotations attached to them, the hoodie in particular with it being something that was once referred to by American talk show host Geraldo Rivera as ‘thug wear’[7] in reference to the shooting of Trayvon Martin. The coloured bandana just goes on to reinforce this idea of the ex being involved in criminal, possibly gang-related activity with the appearance of a golden gun essentially confirming this. It could easily be said though that this links into this idea of a ‘distorted pattern of portrayal’[8] where ‘black males are overrepresented when media touch on certain negative topics, such as criminality, unemployment, and poverty, for instance.’[9] Not only this, but the intricacies behind characters like this never end up being expanded upon, such as why they’re committing the crimes they are, resulting in ‘one-dimensional characters’[10] defined by the many stereotypes associated with the minority group that they’re in (Medhurst). In contrast Joey, who as described by himself, is that ‘cool guy, who is away from all the violence’[11] subverts the stereotype that the ex helps reinforce, creating a sense of binary opposition between the two.

Later in the video on another day, the ex spots Joey and his former girlfriend wandering around the streets with one another and with the same gun shown in the night scene, runs up to him and holds him at gunpoint. A tussle then ensues between them which results in the girl accidentally being shot, the police pulling up nearby just moments after this. As the ex goes back to holding Joey at gunpoint in blame of shooting her, two police officers (one African-American, the other Caucasian) arrive on the scene. Both point their guns at the ex appearing to tell him to drop the weapon and while Joey uses this a chance to flee the area, the ex ends up getting shot in the torso by the black officer. Similarly to the robbery scene, firearms are displayed almost as an all-powerful weapon whether they are in the hands of the police or anyone else for that matter. Whether this iconography’s purpose is solely furthering narrative or adding another level of social commentary on the current issue of police brutality and/or gun violence in the USA as a whole is ambiguous though, and audiences are bound to come away with different views on it. The most notable thing here though is the fact that the ex is murdered at the hands of a black police officer. This alternative representation really works to subvert the stereotype there is that it’s always white officers behind the trigger in cases of police brutality in the USA, while still maintaining the binary opposition (Levi-Strauss) that exists within the police force and black people. This subversion is further cemented when towards the end of the video, this same black officer shoots Joey to death as he runs away from him. Not only does it assert the dominant representation that there is in the media of American police as being trigger-happy, regardless of race, but the way in which Joey dies must be paid attention to since ‘with a hoodie on and his hands raised, Bada$$ embodies some of the most pointed signifiers of these cases.’[12] With the sound cutting out completely after the second gunshot, bar the ominous howling of the wind, and blood splattering on the screen, ‘a resurrection sequence spurred on by halos of white light around the fallen unfolds.’[13] Two of these fallen include other unarmed victims of police brutality, Trayvon Martin and Michael Brown, evidenced with the latter by the white hoodie. This simple yet direct reference to the issue highlights the way the genre of hip hop can act as ‘the most powerful tool when it comes to spreading messages and getting words across,’[14] for artists as Joey puts across himself.

Heralded as ‘making conscious rap […]  trying to point out the problems of African American society to outsiders, critiquing its socioeconomic status and promoting social progress as opposed to criminalization and violence,’[15] it’s no surprise a video of this nature came from Pro Era Records. Founded in 2011 by teenagers ‘born in dangerous neighborhoods and facing many obstacles’[16] non-conformity and anti-establishment sentiments are features that were bound to shine through their content, and the social commentary we see on police brutality (just one of the obstacles) in the Like Me video is illustrative of this. The extent to which this commentary is actually done to raise awareness and eventually solve the issue is questionable though, particularly when you come to find that Pro Era Records is owned by Cinematic Music Group (CMG) as part of Sony Music Entertainment (SME). This ownership by a major record label raises doubts as to whether the video was uploaded to bring about social commentary on police brutality or just further the interests of the parent company. Factor in the date the video was published on (11/02/15), just over 3 weeks after the release of the album the track was on, then it starts to appear that the latter could be true, and maybe the primary purpose of the release of the video was just for product promotion of B4.DA.$$.  Regardless of its primary goal though, the video still speaks volumes on the issue at hand through things like the ‘visual reference to some of the most widely protested cases of young, unarmed black men who have been shot to death’[17] towards the end of it.  It could even be said that perhaps the involvement of a major record label in it is of assistance in the sense that it means the video reaches the masses it needs to ‘to help galvanize a generation’[18] on what’s an increasingly burning issue in modern day society.

Music contemporary Kendrick Lamar, is another artist who has used ‘his “influence” to comment on the ongoing discussion about the killing of black men by white police officers.’[19] His music video for ‘Alright,’ a track off of his To Pimp a Butterfly album released just months after Like Me, doesn’t fall short and in some respects exceeds the feats of social commentary on police brutality achieved by Bada$$ in his video. Featuring ‘striking imagery’[20] throughout of ‘graphic police brutality, the Los Angeles skyline cast in soft, smoggy light, and Kendrick floating through the city’s streets with fire in his eyes’[21] the video is as fascinating as it is disturbing. Releasing in a time (June 30th 2016) when ‘the number of fatal shootings by officers increased from 465 in the first six months of last year to 491 for the same period this year,’[22] Alright couldn’t have come at a more appropriate period than it did. Consider the fact that the shootings of Alton Sterling and Philando Castile took place just under a week after its release, in a rather eerie way at this, and the appropriateness of its time of release is asserted.

Looking at the actual video itself, throughout the intro sequence and entirety of it there’s a monochromatic black-and-white filter which works to establish this quite dark vibe to it, something that already comes with its subject matter. The intro features a variety of different scenes to it, going from one ‘that looks like a kid getting jumped’[23] to all-out ‘rioting’[24] at one point, with a burning police car and a Molotov cocktail being thrown at a graffitied wall. This ‘bleak and almost apocalyptic imagery’[25] doesn’t end here though, and more notably in a way akin to the Like Me video, we see a case of police brutality take place. An officer attempts to make an arrest on a citizen, slamming them against a wall, raising their arms and putting handcuffs on him. Before he can manage to get both on, ‘the man pushes the officer and makes a run for it.’[26] Just as this happens, the officer draws for his pistol and in seemingly mouthing the word ‘freeze,’ the video goes into slow motion zooming into a close-up where the only things in frame are the barrel of the pistol and the ‘POLICE’ hat the officer behind the trigger is wearing. With this the gun discharges, and all that can be assumed from this point is that the arrest victim was shot and killed as the video progresses to the next scene in a straight cut. Unlike Joey’s take on the issue, everyone behind the trigger in this video     (police officers) is white, pertaining to the more dominant reality in high-profile cases of police brutality. All of this is before we see, similarly to Bada$$’s video, the death of the artist himself. Standing on top of a lamppost overlooking the city, dancing to the beat of the song, an officer pulls up nearby. He exits his car with a rifle in hand, though when he shoots Kendrick he does so with two fingers, mimicking a gun. This is followed by him falling back down to the earth as the bullet rips through his body, blood spilling as this happens, while he recites a poem. Eventually he lands and the video cuts to black, but seconds after in a close-up shot of his face, he smiles at the camera. This theme of artists dying in videos appears to be more than just a narrative feature and really what it could be is stressing the mortality that every black man has within America today – famous or not. What’s interesting here is how there’s no sense of new equilibrium (Todorov) reached, as what would be the evil forces/villains (police - Propp) are never defeated and the conflict that goes on between them and black people remains to be. Social commentary on police brutality at this magnitude has eventuated into the song being referred to as ‘the anthem to civil unrest in 2015.’[27]

Throughout #BlackLivesMatter protests in the USA, whether it be against the arrest of a 14-year-old ‘taken in by police after allegedly being intoxicated on a bus’[28] or ‘for the 20th Anniversary of the Million Man March’[29]  the song’s refrain ‘we gon’ be alright’ [30] has been one repeated by thousands across the country. The essence of hope that it contains despite all the odds against ‘police brutality of black and brown bodies,’[31] is something that brings hip-hop back to the ‘form of African-American and bohemian dissent’[32] that it was initially known for. As a ‘resistance mechanism that Blacks utilised to assert their visibility in arenas whose majority players deemed them invisible,’[33] the genre has allowed artists to ‘disseminate information, increase solidarity, fight against injustice, and maintain political and social movements.’[34] Alright is undoubtedly testament to this, and perhaps with its use in actual protests against the issue of police brutality, it could be said that its use of social commentary within both the lyrics and the video went further than Joey Bada$$’s Like Me. Nonetheless though, this commentary going onto solve the issue just like Like Me, is highly unlikely when looking at it realistically.

Having foundations in the ‘principles of rebellion’[35] as a ‘cultural vehicle for open social reflection,’[36] social commentary on police brutality in hip-hop’s earlier days must be cited, with NWA’s ‘F**k tha Police’ being the first port of call for this. Released on August 9th 1988, unlike the other two videos discussed, the track doesn’t have a music video accompanying it. However, this by no means diminishes any of its impact whatsoever. Starting off from a lyrical standpoint, the lyrics featured in F**k tha Police are a lot more incendiary in their nature especially when pitted against tracks we have nowadays speaking out on police brutality. Examples of these lines include ‘I'm a sniper with a hell of a scope, taking out a cop or two, they can't cope with me,’ ‘a sucka in a uniform waitin' to get shot by me, or anotha n***a’ and of course ‘police think they have the authority to kill a minority.’ While a song like ‘Alright’ has the line ‘and we hate po-po, wanna kill us dead in the street fo sho,’ of course in relation to police brutality, Kendrick never goes as far as to advocating the killing of officers and this is representative of how certain sentiments within the relationship between black people and the police have changed. The NWA track essentially contributed to moral panic (Cohen) at the time, evident with the censorship and banning of the performance of the song by police, but regardless of this its impact couldn’t be stopped. The track still remains today ‘a rallying cry for protests against police brutality’[37] almost as if ‘the song was written yesterday’[38] as Ice Cube puts across himself which frankly, is quite a troubling thing to note. This impact is amplified too when you pay attention to the fact that in ‘Like Me,’ Joey says the line: ‘Blacks get their a** sprayed just for making a move, that’s why we get high and say “f**k the police.’ This of course is in direct reference and homage of the NWA song itself, and while Joey doesn’t have that same inflammatory nature that the group had in the lyrics of their song, it’s still clear that their influence has almost been unmatched. Their ‘political critiques’[39] of police and their excessive force is 100% representative as to how hip-hop is an avenue for social commentary on the issue of police brutality.

When we return to modern day though, sadly it can’t be said that hip-hop being used for social commentary on issues like police brutality is a common sight. As the genre has been brought into the mainstream, ‘more defined by codeine and clubbing than raising awareness’[40] there has been an indisputable ‘decline in politically charged material, as major-label hip hop artists began to focus on radio-friendly topics like relationships, personal beefs, and bling.’[41] Something said to have taken over as recent as the year just gone is ‘mumble rap,’ with this involving artists ‘mumbling words over a hard beat - - utilizing the sounds from their mouths as part of the instrumental.’[42] Speaking out on real issues is something that is becoming more and more of a rarity within the genre, and this has been a gradual process that has meant that ‘over the past decade it has been lulled into being a conservative instrument, promoting nothing now or remotely challenging to mainstream cultural ideology.’[43]  With the immense influence that these artists have over their audiences as opinion leaders (Katz and Lazarsfeld), some in society possess this worry that young people particularly will be negatively affected by the kind of messages that this music shares. Described as the ‘cultural arm of predatory capitalism,’[44] ‘blaring redundant, glossy messages of violence without consequence, misogyny and conspicuous consumption,’[45] people cultivating views (G. Gerbner) that reflect music like this can spark a moral panic in the sense that copycats can start to spring up and audiences can become desensitised to things which they shouldn’t be as they’re ‘injected’ (hypodermic needle model) with certain values through the music.

But perhaps in the future, social commentary on police brutality could ascend the boundaries of hip-hop altogether. Citizen journalism, ‘the collection, dissemination, and analysis of news and information by the general public, especially by means of the Internet,’[46] seems to be doing exactly what the genre intended to do in its inception. With it involving, at least in respects to police brutality specifically, someone recording a show of excessive force by an officer on a citizen and then uploading this onto social media to where it circulates, local issues get brought to a global stage. This same filming as of recent ‘has led to a wave of protests and calls for reform across the US,’[47] and what’s really interesting here is that these demonstrations are being driven by predominantly black people, all through a cameraphone. Just like hip-hop/rap, which ‘Blacks utilised to assert their visibility in arenas whose majority players deemed them invisible,’[48] citizen journalism is allowing those that we may never heard a peep from before, to speak out on injustices they happen to bear witness to. Something worth looking at over the next few months is the impact that the inauguration of President-elect Donald Trump will have on this type of journalism. Having announced plans to ‘take the controversial stop-and-frisk practice nationwide,’[49] it’s not outlandish to think that the amount of these kind of citizen journalism videos could rise, as these practices are often prone to targeting black people the most. As it is, this seems like the inevitable reality that it is going to have to take place but only time will tell if it comes into fruition.

In conclusion, it can be said that hip-hop is instrumental in allowing for social commentary on the issue of police brutality to quite a considerable extent. As the ‘town hall for the culture, a sounding board, a place to vent […] to help galvanise a generation,’[50] it allows those within the very margins of modern America, the opportunity to comment on an issue that if not for its  existence [hip-hop], would only be covered by the media. With it, through all the adversity, comes gems which we see in the form of songs like Like Me by Joey Bada$$ and Kendrick Lamar’s Alright. It does have to be remarked though that perhaps galvanising is all hip-hop’s commentary on police brutality can do. Member of Geto Boys, Big Mike, in an intro to the song ‘Crooked Officer,’ released back in 1993, stated that: ‘The song’s not enough, the song is just saying we need to take some kind of action. This is just the beginning in the step towards the right way.’[51] What’s being said here is that although the song gets the social commentary necessary across that they want, he understands that it’s something that’ll only capture the attention of certain members of the public on the issue and not actually outright stop it. Looking at the use of a song like Alright as a protest anthem for police brutality and it’s clear that this may be the case. The song doesn’t solve problems, but rather just raises awareness of them and perhaps that’s all that’s actually needed on the road to getting to the solution of issues of its kin.


Bibliography

Asante, M. (2008). It’s Bigger Than Hip Hop: The Rise of the Post-Hip Hop Generation. In M. Asante, It’s Bigger Than Hip Hop: The Rise of the Post-Hip Hop Generation. St. Martin's Press.

Bonnette, L. M. (2015). Pulse of the People: Political Music and Black Politics. In L. M. Bonnette, Pulse of the People: Political Music and Black Politics (p. 2). University of Pennsylvania Press.

Bonnette, L. M. (2015). Pulse of the People: Political Rap Music and Black Politics. In L. M. Bonnette, Pulse of the People: Political Rap Music and Black Politics (p. 8). University of Pennsylvania Press.

Bradner, E. (2016, September 22). Clinton, Trump navigate politics of police violence. Retrieved from CNN: http://edition.cnn.com/2016/09/21/politics/police-shootings-politics-trump-clinton/

Canon, G. (2015, February 11). In A New Video, Joey Bada$$ Takes on Police Shootings. Retrieved from Mother Jones: http://www.motherjones.com/media/2015/02/joey-badass-new-video-premiere-like-me-police-brutality

Carter, K. L. (2015, August 14). The Painful, Long, And Lasting Legacy Of “Fuck Tha Police” - BuzzFeed. Retrieved from BuzzFeed: https://www.buzzfeed.com/kelleylcarter/how-fuck-tha-police-started-a-revolution?utm_term=.sqxB898P8#.yovDXAX3X

Complex News. (2015, October 10). Thousands Chant Kendrick Lamar’s “Alright” at Million Man March Gathering. Retrieved from YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JnYCwQcryyc

Cox, J. (2015, June 30). Watch Kendrick Lamar's bold, cinematic video for 'Alright'. Retrieved from The Verge: www.theverge.com/2015/6/30/8872979/kendrick-lamar-alright-music-video-new-single

Danilina, S. (2010). What Is Police Brutality? - The Law Dictionary. Retrieved from The Law Dictionary: http://thelawdictionary.org/article/what-is-police-brutality/

Darron T. Smith, P. (2013, March 14). Images of Black Males in Popular Media | The Huffington Post. Retrieved from The Huffington Post: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/darron-t-smith-phd/black-men-media_b_2844990.html

Desta, Y. (2015, July 1). Kendrick Lamar drops chilling music video about police brutality. Retrieved from Mashable: mashable.com/2015/07/01/kendrick-lamar-alright-video-police-brutality/#u96uM3uwogqo

Diazmuñoz, C. (2006, September 9). Crooked Officer Geto Boys - YouTube. Retrieved from YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vNEyiuUsgjk

Dixon, S. (2015, November 30). Of guns 'n rappers: hip hop and moral panic – A•STAR. Retrieved from A•STAR: http://astar.tv/post/of-guns-n-rappers-hip-hop-and-moral-panic/

Elliott-Cooper, A. (2012, October 29). Tricia Rose: “Hip-Hop can be a poetic force for a social movement”. Retrieved from Ceasefire Magazine: https://ceasefiremagazine.co.uk/tricia-rose-hip-hop-poetic-force-social-movement/

Genius. (2015, March 15). Kendrick Lamar – Alright Lyrics | Genius Lyrics. Retrieved from Genius: http://genius.com/Kendrick-lamar-alright-lyrics

Guardian Music. (2015, July 29). Activists chant Kendrick Lamar's Alright during police harassment protest. Retrieved from The Guardian: https://www.theguardian.com/music/2015/jul/29/activists-chant-kendrick-lamar-track-alright-police-harassment-protests

Harris, A. (2015, August 3). Has Kendrick Lamar Recorded the New Black National Anthem? Retrieved from Slate: http://www.slate.com/articles/arts/culturebox/2015/08/black_lives_matter_protesters_chant_kendrick_lamar_s_alright_what_makes.html

Hunte, J. (2015, September 9). Ex-Cops Reflect On Impact Of "Fuck Tha Police" | HipHopDX. Retrieved from HipHopDX: http://hiphopdx.com/news/id.35418/title.ex-cops-reflect-on-impact-of-fuck-tha-police

Iandoli, K. (2016, December 21). 'Mumble Rap': Did Lyricism Take a Hit in 2016? | Billboard. Retrieved from www.billboard.com/articles/columns/hip-hop/7625631/rise-of-mumble-rap-lyricism-2016

Karakurt, A. (2015, February 9). The Renaissance of New York’s Conscious Hip-Hop Scene. Retrieved from Bilkent News: http://bilnews.bilkent.edu.tr/the-renaissance-of-new-yorks-conscious-hip-hop-scene/

Kerschhagel, M. (2011, November 30). Opportunity for Black Men and Boys: Public Opinion, Media Depictions, and Media Consumption. Retrieved from The Opportunity Agenda: https://opportunityagenda.org/files/field_file/2011.11.30%20%7C%20Report%20%7C%20Opportunity%20for%20Black%20Men%20and%20Boys%20%7C%20FINAL.pdf

Kimberly Kindy, W. L. (2016, July 7). Fatal shootings by police are up in the first six months of 2016, Post analysis finds. Retrieved from The Washington Post: https://www.washingtonpost.com/national/fatal-shootings-by-police-surpass-2015s-rate/2016/07/07/81b708f2-3d42-11e6-84e8-1580c7db5275_story.html?utm_term=.9119154b4579

King, J. (2016, February 11). The Improbable Story of How Kendrick Lamar's "Alright" Became a Protest Anthem. Retrieved from Mic: https://mic.com/articles/134764/the-improbable-story-of-how-kendrick-lamar-s-alright-became-a-protest-anthem#.z1b33xyv6

Makarechi, K. (2015, June 30). Kendrick Lamar’s Disturbing “Alright” Video Tackles Police Brutality. Retrieved from Vanity Fair: http://www.vanityfair.com/culture/2015/06/kendrick-lamar-alright-video

Moore, C. (2015, August 14). Mass Appeal — “Fuck Tha Police”: N.W.A's Most Courageous Song Is Still As Relevant As Ever. Retrieved from Mass Appeal: http://massappeal.com/fuck-tha-police-nwa-most-courageous-song-is-still-as-relevant-as-ever/

Nguyen, D. V. (2015, July 30). Civil rights activists chant Kendrick Lamar's 'Alright' during police harassment protest. Retrieved from NME: www.nme.com/news/music/kendrick-lamar-50-1226359

Oxford Dictionaries. (n.d.). citizen journalism - definition of citizen journalism in English | Oxford Dictionaries. Retrieved from Oxford Dictionaries: https://en.oxforddictionaries.com/definition/citizen_journalism

Piffin, B. (2015, July 28). Police harassment leads to crowd singing Kendrick Lamar's "Alright". Retrieved from YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VUC_DOhfzwQ

Rinaldi, E. (2015, September 2). Prophets of pain: the art of NWA's F*** tha Police - The Conversation. Retrieved from The Conversation: http://theconversation.com/prophets-of-pain-the-art-of-nwas-f-tha-police-46931

Rogers, A. (2012, July 13). Now Geraldo Rivera Is Blaming Chicago's Murder Spike On 'Thug Wear'. Retrieved from Business Insider: http://www.businessinsider.com/geraldo-rivera-thug-wear-comments-2012-7?IR=T

Rose, T. (1994). Black Noise:Rap Music and Black Culture in Contemporary America. In T. Rose, Black Noise:Rap Music and Black Culture in Contemporary America. Middletown: Wesleyan University Press.

Singleton, J. (Director). (1991). Boyz n the Hood [Motion Picture].

Spanos, B. (2015, February 12). Joey Bada$$ Takes on Police Shootings in ‘Like Me’ Video. Retrieved from Rolling Stone: http://www.rollingstone.com/music/videos/joey-bada-takes-on-police-shootings-in-like-me-video-20150212

Spence, L. K. (2011). Stare in the Darkness: The Limits of Hip-Hop and Black Politics. In L. K. Spence, Stare in the Darkness: The Limits of Hip-Hop and Black Politics (p. 23). Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.

Staff, N. (2016, July 8). Joey Bada$$ writes impassioned response to the death of Alton Sterling. Retrieved from Noisey: http://noisey.vice.com/en_uk/blog/joey-bada-writes-impassioned-response-to-the-death-of-alton-sterling

Talbert, S. T. (2015, August 11). Kendrick Lamar's Theology of Alright. Retrieved from The Huffington Post: www.huffingtonpost.com/stanley-t-talbert/kendrick-lamars-theology-b_7956752.html

The Hilltop. (2015, October 10). The Hilltop on Twitter: "Chants of @kendricklamar's "Alright" echoes down 7th street downtown. #JusticeOrElse". Retrieved from Twitter: https://twitter.com/thehilltophu/status/652838787492519936

Thompson, D. (2015, December 11). How Kendrick Lamar's "Alright" Became The Anthem To Civil Unrest in 2015. Retrieved from Vibe: www.vibe.com/2015/12/kendrick-lamar-alright-protest-anthem-2015/

Timm, T. (2016, August 10). People who film police violence are citizen journalists. We stand with them. Retrieved from The Guardian: https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2016/aug/10/filming-police-violence-citizen-journalists-first-amendment

White, C. (2015, February 11). Joey Bada$$ – “Like Me” (Feat. BJ The Chicago Kid) Video. Retrieved from Stereogum: http://www.stereogum.com/1737480/joey-bada-like-me-feat-bj-the-chicago-kid-video/video/

Williams, S. (2016, July 11). Hip-Hop's History with Police Brutality: Why We Should Live in the Now. Retrieved from The Daily Beast: http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2016/07/11/hip-hop-s-history-with-police-brutality-why-we-shouldn-t-romanticize-the-ogs-and-live-in-the-now.html

Yoh. (2015, July 2). The Definitive Breakdown of Kendrick Lamar's “Alright” Video | DJBooth. Retrieved from DJBooth: djbooth.net/news/entry/2015-07-2-breakdown-kendrick-lamar-alright-video





[1] Asante, M. (2008).  p. ???
[2] Spence, Lester K. (2011). p. 23.
[3] Asante, M.K. (2008). p. ???
[4] Danilina, S. (2010)
[5] Spanos, B. (2015)
[6] White, C. (2015)
[7] Rogers, A. (2012)
[8] Kerschhagel, M. (2011)
[9] ibid
[10] (Darron T. Smith, 2013)
[11] Canon, G. (2015)
[12] Spanos, B. (2015)
[13] White, C. (2015)
[14] Spanos, B. (2015)
[15] Karakurt, A. (2015)
[16] ibid
[17] Spanos, B. (2015)
[18] Stereo, W. (2016)
[19] Makarechi, K. (2015)
[20] Cox, J. (2015)
[21] ibid
[22] Kindy, K. (2015)
[23] Yoh. (2015)
[24] ibid
[25] ibid
[26] ibid
[27] Thompson, D. (2015)
[28] Nguyen, D. V. (2015)
[29] Complex News. (2015)
[30] Genius. (2015)
[31] ibid
[32] Asante, M. (2008). p. ???
[33] Bonette, L. M. (2015) p. 8.
[34] ibid
[35] Asante, M. (2008). p. ???
[36] Rose, T. (1994). p. 18.
[37] Moore, C. (2015)
[38] Carter, K.L. (2015)
[39] Spence, L. K. (2011). p. 2
[40] William, S. (2016)
[41] Moore, C. (2015)
[42] Iandoli, K. (2015)
[43] Asante, M. (2008). p. ???
[44] Elliot-Cooper, A. (2012)
[45] (Asante, 2008)
[46] (Oxford Dictionaries, n.d.)
[47] (Timm, 2016)
[48] Bonette, L. M. (2015) p. 8.
[49] (Bradner, 2016)
[50] Williams, S. (2016)
[51] Diazmuñoz, C. (2006)

Wednesday, 2 November 2016

Notes and quotes (2012 words)


Notes and quotes (2012 words)

Joey Bada$$ – Like Me (primary text)

Internet links

1.    Joey Bada$$ Takes on Police Shootings in ‘Like Me’ Video
·         ‘Last few years of heightened public attention to shootings of unarmed black men”
·         “Joey Bada$$ has taken his rapidly rising status and platform to speak out on what it means to be young and black in America”
·         “The powerful clip features visual reference to some of the most widely protested cases of young, unarmed black men who have been shot to death, including Trayvon Martin and Michael Brown”
·         “With a hoodie on and his hands raised, Bada$$ embodies some of the most pointed signifiers of these cases”
·         “Bada$$ is one of several hip hop artists to not only speak against police violence, but use their art as a form of protest”

2.    In a New Video, Joey Bada$$ Takes on Police Shootings
·         “Bada$$ credits Nas as a source of inspiration, and, like Nas, he's using his beats and metaphors to highlight social ills”
·         "I think music is the most powerful tool when it comes to spreading messages and getting words across"
·         "My way of protesting is through my music […] with this newfound stature I have this voice where if I say something, a lot of people listen to it"

3.    Joey Bada$$ writes impassioned response to the death of Alton Sterling
·         “Joey Bada$$ has spoken up about police brutality plenty in his career, not least in the video for “Like Me” at the start of last year”
·         “What the government is doing amongst our people is downright disturbing but not surprising”
·         “The code words to killing black men is “he has a gun!” That gives them the rights and incentives to shoot and most of the time it’s just a cellphone, wallet or a downright lie!”
·         “I’m tired of putting up these hashtags every time another story hits the media… What are we going to do? When will true justice be served?”

4.    Hip-Hop’s History with Police Brutality: Why We Should Live in the Now
·         ‘Black celebrities have voiced concern for the state of race relations in America and solidarity with a community that feels more under attack than ever.’
·         ‘We can oftentimes overstate the significance of having very famous people lend their voices to the social challenges of the day. They can’t be counted on to be the most informed on issues, and it’s juvenile to assume that someone is qualified to address weighty societal problems just because they’ve made a lot of money singing, playing a sport, or acting.’
·         But because so many view contemporary hip-hop as more defined by codeine and clubbing than raising awareness, there’s a lingering belief that today’s rappers don’t care like their forbears did. Hip-hop is no longer black people’s CNN, but perhaps it’s become something different: more of a town hall for the culture, a sounding board, a place to vent as opposed to a source of information. And maybe that’s still enough to help galvanize a generation. It certainly seems to be.
·         Celebrities speaking out doesn't solve problems but it does make it harder for consumers of all colors to ignore those problems when their favorite is calling for it to be addressed. 
PDF

1.    Opportunity for Black Men and Boys: Public Opinion, Media Depictions, and Media Consumption
·         Distorted pattern of portrayal:

-        black men are underrepresented overall in the media in terms of factual programming and as relatable fictional characters
-        negative associations are exaggerated so black men are shown to be connected with criminality, unemployment and poverty more than is truthful
-        positive associations for black men are limited to entertainment, mainly those linked to physical achievement such as sport
-        black males tend to be associated with problems that are impossible to solve
-        the historical context of black men’s lives is missing from the media, such as reasons for black economic disadvantage

Books

1.    M.K. Asante – It’s Bigger Than Hip Hop: The Rise of the Post-Hip Hop Generation

·         ‘Post-hip-hop is an assertion of agency that encapsulates this generation’s broad range of abilities, ideals, and ideas, as well as incorporates recent social advances and movements’
·         ‘When we consider hip hop’s origins and purpose, we understand it is a revolutionary cultural force that was intended to challenge the status quo and greater American culture.’
·         ‘Although hip hop was founded on the principles of rebellion, over the past decade it has been lulled into being a conservative instrument, promoting nothing now or remotely challenging to mainstream cultural ideology. Even in the midst of an illegitimate war in Iraq, rap music remains a stationary vehicle blaring redundant, glossy messages of violence without consequence, misogyny and conspicuous consumption. As a result, it has betrayed the very people it is supposed to represent; it has betrayed itself.’
·         ‘In hip’s case, and the same is true for hip hop, Scott Saul, professor of English at Berkeley, points out that “it [hip] moved from a form of African-American and bohemian dissent to the become the very language of the advertising world, which took hip’s promise of authenticity, liberation and rebellion and attached it to the act of enjoying whatever was on sale at the moment.’

2.    Stare in the Darkness: The Limits of Hip-hop and Black Politics
·         ‘We can, too, take songs like “F*ck Da Police” and examine them as political critiques against the growing role police play in the expansion of the American prison industrial complex. But though black citizens in cities across the country rail as much against police brutality as they do against black-on-black crime, there is no significant anti-police brutality movement led by prominent rap MCs.’
·         ‘Perry defines rap realism as rap that is chiefly concerned with the social conditions of (black) working-class (urban life)’

3.    Pulse of the People: Political Rap Music and Black Politics
·         ‘Clearly, Hip-Hop has a strong relationship with political and social issues’
·         Culture-specifically Black music – historically has been a resistance mechanism that Blacks utilised to assert their visibility in arenas whose majority players deemed them invisible. Blacks have used culture to disseminate information, increase solidarity, fight against injustice, and maintain political and social movements.

Other media texts

YG – One Time Comin’


This music video for the YG song ‘One Time Comin,’ in dedication for the victims of police brutality, presents not only the artist in a car chase with the police but also another black man in an on-foot chase with an officer. The latter of the two chases ends in the man being shot (off-screen) by the white officer, of course working to depict what’s now come to be a more prevalent instance in the U.S.A. What’s also quite interesting to note here is the way in which this on-foot chase is displayed, which is predominantly through the lens of a police body camera. This is quite timely as there have been more calls for the wider use of body cameras recently, as well as concerns being expressed with their use.

Vic Mensa – 16 Shots

Again with a music video, quite similar to the one above, Vic Mensa’s ’16 Shots’ presents the issue of police brutality in both a more graphic and disturbing way. Displaying Mensa being riddled with bullets by multiple police officers, the video really helps reflect the hard reality that there is with each case of police brutality. Helping to get this across even more is the inclusion of the dash cam footage showing the shooting of Laquan McDonald. This is aided not only with a monologue describing the events that took place in his shooting, but also in another scene that there are jumps between with an actor mirroring the body language of Laquan in his final moments. This was particularly effective in conveying what is often the case time and time again, with cases of police brutality.

Kendrick Lamar – Alright


The music video for the Kendrick Lamar song ‘Alright,’ which has been heralded as one of ‘the songs of Black Lives Matter’ by Rolling Stone, shares most of its similarities with 16 Shots. Displaying a narrative where a fleeing suspect (black man) is shot by a white police officer and also accompanied by a monologue, this time by the artist himself describing the current racial discrimination that goes on, a real dark, harsh vibe is given of the USA today. 

Elements such as the monochromatic, black and white filter which is present throughout the entirety of the video only help contribute to this but the visuals in the video itself are what really strike as being quite powerful in terms of social commentary. One scene in it for example shows Lamar and other members of the rap group he’s in being carried by 4 policemen in a car as he raps along to a different track. What’s quite interesting to remark on here though is that the audience could either perceive this as in some way at least, a form of representing ascendancy above the injustices that the police force have made over recent years or the car that the officers are holding the rappers in is a casket and they’re the pallbearers for it. As all 4 of the rappers are black men, perhaps it’s just going to show that anyone despite their position in society or success can often be a victim to police brutality simply on the basis of their skin.

The final part of the video in a way akin to ’16 Shots,’ shows the artist himself being a victim the hands of the police. Standing on top of the lamppost a policeman can be seen ‘shooting’ Lamar down and we’re presented with a shot of him in slow motion hurtling back down to the earth. Just after he hits the ground though after he’s supposedly killed, a close-up shot of him smiling is shown and maybe this is done with the purpose of matching up with the hook/refrain that’s sang throughout the track which is ‘we gon’ be alright.’

TI – Warzone


In this music video, the artist himself which in this case is TI takes more of a backseat just rapping along to the lyrics of the song. However what is really striking here is the narrative of the video and how it flips or inverts what we’re usually used to seeing in society where black people are the ones marginalised by other groups. Instead what we see is white people in this position through different walks of life.

Throughout the video there are clear re-enactments of cases of police brutality all the way from Tamir Rice evident with the kid playing around with a toy gun, Eric Garner as you can more or less tell he’s saying ‘I can’t breathe’ and also Philando Castile as we’re shown a shooting happening with 3 seated passengers, one of which being a baby and the other another of an adult filming the aftermath of the shooting for a live broadcast. The only difference in all of this though is that all of the victims were white and the police officers were black. It’s evident that this was done with the purpose of perhaps being a wakeup call to groups other than black people in America, to not just sit down and allow injustices like this to take place anymore. The audio extract of Jane Elliot asking a white audience whether they’d want to ‘be treated the way blacks are’ only helps further get this across as it really does work to galvanise audiences to stop being passive to things that they know aren’t right.

Usher - Chains by Film the Future ft. Nas, Bibi Bourelly

Although this video is a lot less graphic than the ones before, it still does help represent what now seems to be the current sentiment towards the police brutality. In the video we see people, particularly young people wearing clothing like hoodies, holding up signs that read things such as ‘JUST FOLLOWING ORDERS’ and ‘AM I NEXT?’ just representing the tension that exists between the police and the black community in particular.


Thursday, 6 October 2016

Critical Investigation: Project proposal


Critical Investigation: Project proposal


Working title

'To what extent is hip-hop instrumental in allowing for social commentary on the issue of police brutality'

Angle

What impact is hip-hop music having on the general public's perception of police brutality and do they perceive it in a positive light in the sense that it acts as a therapeutic means to 

Hypothesis


Linked production piece

A music video relating to police brutality, perhaps from a UK perspective. The track used for it could be one of the ones mentioned below or a newer one.


MIGRAIN


  • What are the dominant images and iconography, and what is their relevance to the major themes of the text?
  • Iconography that sticks out especially in the music video is firearms. Throughout the video whether it's in the hands of a criminal or the police, the gun appears as both a pivotal and all-powerful object. While this might just be for the sake of progression in the narrative, it has to be said that it really does seem that this targets yet another issue ingrained in American society - gun violence. Whether it's intentional or not though, just adds to the ambiguity that the video itself has
  • To what extent are the audience’s generic expectations of the text fulfilled or cheated by the text? Does the text conform to the characteristics of the genre, or does it treat them playfully or ironically?
  • As a whole the video doesn't conform to the general characteristics of hip-hop videos to quite a large extent. It doesn't portray women as being interchangeable, doesn't glorify gang violence and neither does it work to aid the braggadocio of the artist himself, all things we typically see in hip hop music videos. In this sense the generic expectations of the audience aren't really fulfilled at all and rather the video ignores a lot of these in place for a more meaningful narrative-based affair on a significant current issue
  • In what ways has the text been influenced or shaped by the institution which produced it?
  • We see the label's [Pro Era's] identity being an influence through the more 'conscious' direction the video takes, with the label recognised for being particularly vocal on world issues such as racial discrimination and just being quite anti-establishment as a whole - non-conformity
  • What are the major values, ideologies and assumptions underpinning the text or naturalised within it?
  • The values and ideologies we're presented with in 'Like Me' is that racial discrimination as a whole, which ends up leading to things like police brutality has to stop because even those doing no wrong in the eyes of the law can simply become another statistic due to the carelessness of one person. This too matches up with what Pro Era as an institution is associated with as said before, blasting things like discrimination and the establishment that exists in the world

  • How do you, as an audience member, read and evaluate the text? To what extent is your reading and evaluation influenced by your age, gender, background etc?
  • Personally, I would say that the video is quite enlightening on the current injustices that take place within the USA. I can also manage to identify with it too because I myself am a young black male. Although I'm living in the UK it constantly makes me imagine how different life would be if I lived in the States and how I wouldn't be able to do certain things I do here with no worry there and how you could easily become just another statistic, innocent or not. As a fan of hip hop too, I feel that I'm able to connect with the video even further with such an important issue being displayed through a medium that I really enjoy. 

SHEP

Social - 

Historical - from this aspect, there an ample amount of cases of police brutality that have occurred in the United States to look at. One of the more notable ones would be the Rodney King case in which four police officers were caught on camera beating up taxi driver, Rodney King

Economical - 

Political - from a political standpoint the particularly controversial 2nd Amendment comes to mind as this is what states that people have the right to bear arms. While this remains in the Constitution, (black) people have still been killed for possession of them putting pressure particularly on Barack Obama to assess the changes that he could possibly make to it

Issues/Debates

  • Racism
  • Stereotypes
  • Connotation
  • Consumerism
  • Demonisation?
  • Product placement


Theories

  • Binary opposition - here it links particularly to the black community and the police force who tend to be at opposing ends of the spectrum
  • Preferred reading - relates to the portrayal of young black people in the media as being menaces to society
  • Propp's character types - police generally fit within the 'villain' character type particularly just after cases of police shootings
  • Audience theories -
  • Two-step model - links as the social commentary on the issue is done through hip-hop music which is created by quite well known musicians (opinion leaders)
  • Cultivation theory - this music can often mean that listeners develop views that quite strongly oppose police brutality, possibly to even more extreme levels

Research plan (media texts, academic texts and websites)

Media text
  • Joey Bada$$ - Like Me
Other media texts
  • Kendrick Lamar - Alright
  • Killer Mike - Pressure ft. Ice Cube
  • NWA - Straight Outta Compton
  • Vince Staples - Hands Up
  • YG - Police Get Away Wit Murder
Academic texts/books

Tuesday, 27 September 2016

Ignite presentation learner response


Ignite presentation learner response

Police brutality in popular culture

1)
  • Clear opening + use of technology grabs attention (good use of GIF)
  • Confident, authoritative delivery although perhaps needed a tiny bit more rehearsal (a little bit rushed)
  • Touches on many interesting aspects - covers many concepts but perhaps it could be a case of 'less is more'... the points on representation are fascinating and surely deserving of more than 30 seconds!
  • Excellent media analysis with confident use of media terminology
  • Similarly, good summary of theories which are appropriate and fit the issues addressed
  • Powerful ending that has an impact on the audience and also draws attention to the consequences of these issues that can get lost in media coverage
  • I'd like to have seen a little more on media effects and how hip hop can contribute to these debates
  • Potentially #BlackLivesMatter campaign could have been included
  • Excellent opening question on stereotypes - and answered confidently in real depth. Answer naturally uses media terminology - great to see
  • Honest, passionate and knowledgeable in Q+A
  • Some superb questions - particularly on the institutional racism of the police against individual officers' ethnicity

Content - 5/5
Clarity - 5/5
Presentation - 4/5

= 14

WWW:
  • Good application of things like media terminology and theories
  • Discussed how the more 'human' aspects, get lost within these news stories
EBI:
  • Inclusion of current movement/issues such as the #BlackLivesMatter campaign could take the investigation further
  • Could have discussed one of the academic texts I researched relating to how hip hop has furthered things like the concept of black empowerment and also how it's often used as a tool to speak out issues facing the black community
  • Make sure to focus on particular issues in good detail as oppose to looking at a lot in less

2)

My presentation will lead into my critical investigation in that I have more of an idea of what specifically to look at regarding my topic due to the feedback I received. #BlackLivesMatter will be something good in particular to look at and the impact hip-hop is having on their movement against police brutality. Additionally to make this even better, I'll have to take the time to read books such as M.K. Asante's It's Bigger Than Hip Hop to develop a greater insight and better understanding into the how the music genre is being increasingly used as something of a vehicle for social commentary on issues facing the artists behind it, and not solely for commercial means. Scholarly articles would be of good use too to help me with my investigations, for example Rap: The Cry of a Rebuked People by Willie Howard discussing how the genre has become somewhat of a coping mechanism for the oppression black people go through in the States. Something I want to ensure while looking at this though is that I focus on police brutality, and while I inevitably have to discuss racial discrimination, I have to remember that it's a huge umbrella for police brutality (towards black people in particular) comes under.